|The greatest happiness is to know the source of unhappiness. - Dostoevsky|
RFE/RL NEWSLINE Vol 2, No. 48, Part I, 11 March 1998
___________________________________________________________ RFE/RL NEWSLINE Vol 2, No. 48, Part I, 11 March 1998 A daily report of developments in Eastern and Southeastern Europe, Russia, the Caucasus and Central Asia prepared by the staff of Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty. This is Part I, a compilation of news concerning Russia, Transcaucasia and Central Asia. Part II covers Central, Eastern, and Southeastern Europe and is distributed simultaneously as a second document. Back issues of RFE/RL NewsLine and the OMRI Daily Digest are online at RFE/RL's Web site: http://www.rferl.org/newsline xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx ALL BROADCASTS FOR SIX SERVICES LIVE ONLINE All programs of RFE/RL's Armenian, Azerbaijani, Bulgarian, Kyrgyz, Russian and Ukrainian Services are online live in RealAudio. The Russian Service broadcasts 24 hours a day, seven days a week. To tune in, go to: http://www.rferl.org/realaudio/ xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Headlines, Part I * GORE-CHERNOMYRDIN COMMISSION MEETS IN WASHINGTON * YELTSIN CONCERNED ABOUT INSTABILITY IN NORTH CAUCASUS * GEORGIA TO PRESENT NEW PLAN FOR CIS * End Note: WHAT PRICE BAKU-CEYHAN? xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx RUSSIA GORE-CHERNOMYRDIN COMMISSION MEETS IN WASHINGTON... The 10th session of the Russian-U.S. Commission on Economic and Technical Cooperation, also called the Gore-Chernomyrdin Commission, began in Washington on 10 March. The commission focused initially on Russia's contribution to the Alpha space station. Construction of that station is scheduled to begin this summer, but it seems unlikely Russia will be able to come up with the $21 billion it has pledged. Russian Prime Minister Viktor Chernomyrdin and U.S. Vice President Al Gore are scheduled to meet with executives of the U.S. companies Lockheed-Martin and Boeing to discuss cooperation in launching commercial satellites and helping Russia raise money for its space program. Cooperation in health care was also discussed, particularly with regard to AIDS and tuberculosis. Russian Health Minister Tatyana Dmitrieva, who also attended the meeting, said "never before have the questions of health care been examined in such detail." She added Russia is requesting loans from the U.S. to help fund the fight against infectious diseases. BP ...WILL LIKELY DISCUSS RUSSIA'S USE OF SUPERCOMPUTERS. U.S. State Department deputy spokesman James Foley said on 10 March that Russia has twice turned down formal U.S. government requests for information on U.S.-made supercomputers allegedly being used in Russian nuclear research facilities. Foley said the issue will likely be a topic of discussion among commission members. The U.S. government is concerned that five high-speed Silicon Graphics and IBM computers, sold in 1997 without licenses, are now in use at the Chelyabinsk and Arzamas nuclear development facilities. The Russian Prosecutor-General's Office has rejected a request from the U.S. Justice Department for assistance in investigating the sale and use of those computers, the "Washington Times" reported on 10 March. BP YELTSIN CONCERNED ABOUT INSTABILITY IN NORTH CAUCASUS. At a Kremlin meeting on 10 March with elders from all regions in the North Caucasus except Chechnya, President Boris Yeltsin said he is "worried by the unstable situation" there and especially by "the growing distaste that people show for local as well as federal officials," Interfax reported. But while promising assistance to the region and even suggesting he might pay a personal visit there, Yeltsin said that Russia is a "great multinational state that feared no one from [U.S. President Bill] Clinton to anyone else" and will do what it has to do to ensure stability across its territory. Earlier, Russian Deputy Prime Minister Ramazan Abdulatipov said Moscow is ready for any compromises on problems in the North Caucasus as long as they do not undermine Russia's territorial integrity, ITAR-TASS reported. But he suggested that there are no ethnic conflicts in that region, only "struggles for high posts." PG QUESTIONABLE CRITERIA USED FOR CHOOSING ELDERS. While the Kremlin built up expectations over Yeltsin's meeting with the elders, the regions of the North Caucasus do not have consensus figures whose views carry widespread authority and influence over political developments. In most cases, residents of the regions learned the names of their "elders" only a few days before the delegations flew to Moscow, RFE/RL's correspondent in Vladikavkaz reported on 10 March. Many delegates were former Soviet officials. For instance, the North Ossetian delegation included a Brezhnev-era trade minister. Among the "elders" chosen by the Republic of Kabardino-Balkaria was a former NKVD officer who participated in the deportation of Balkars in 1945, RFE/RL's Moscow bureau reported. RFE/RL commentator Andrei Babitskii, an expert on the North Caucasus, described the concept of "elders" as grounded in "fairy tales" rather than current political realities. LB IDEA OF 'ELDERS' TAINTED IN CHECHNYA. Chechen President Aslan Maskhadov snubbed Moscow by not sending any elders from the breakaway republic to meet with Yeltsin. But even if he had wanted to send representatives to the meeting, selecting them would have been extremely problematic, RFE/RL's Grozny correspondent reported on 10 March. The term "elder" has negative connotations in Chechnya, where it is assumed to refer to a person appointed by Moscow. The last person to use the services of "elders" was Doku Zavgaev, who headed the pro-Moscow Chechen government during the war in Chechnya. Those elders were mainly old party officials and veterans of Soviet agencies who, on behalf of their villages, signed a protocol recognizing Zavgaev's government in the hope of escaping bombardment by Russian forces. LB CHECHEN PRESIDENT CALLS FOR INTERNATIONAL COMMISSION. In remarks to the London-based Royal Institute of International Affairs, Maskhadov said he had told former British Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher that he would like an international commission to examine the extent to which Russia has kept to its promises on Chechnya. Citing Winston Churchill's observation that Russia has no tradition of living up to its commitments, Maskhadov said he did not expect the commission to find that it had. And noting that Russia had no money, he added that Grozny does not expect to obtain promised funds from Moscow. In conclusion, Maskhadov repeated his argument that Chechnya is an independent country: "To those who say we have to break away from Russia, we say: 'Find a single document which says we are legally part of Russia. Such a document does not exist.'" PG LONDON PRESSES MASKHADOV ON HOSTAGES. A British Foreign Office official told Maskhadov that London cannot consider providing any assistance to Chechnya until there is a settlement of the conflict and until all hostages are released, ITAR-TASS reported on 10 March. Maskhadov told the BBC that he has done everything he can to secure the release of the hostages and will continue to do so. PG BASAEV PESSIMISTIC ABOUT TALKS WITH RUSSIA. Chechen acting Prime Minister Shamil Basaev on 11 March questioned the use of holding further talks between Moscow and Grozny, saying Russia has "proved to be a bad partner," Interfax reported. Basaev charged that the Russian side has not implemented any of the agreements it signed with Chechen authorities. As for a planned meeting between Chechen Foreign Minister Movladi Udugov and Russian Deputy Prime Minister Ivan Rybkin, Basaev predicted the two men will "have a cup of tea, exchange diplomatic niceties, and...interpret the results of the meeting differently." Basaev led a raid on the town of Budennovsk (Stavropol Krai) in June 1995. The Russian Prosecutor-General's Office brought criminal charges against him, which have not yet been dropped. LB YELTSIN WANTS TIGHTER CONTROL OVER WELFARE SPENDING. Deputy Prime Minister Oleg Sysuev says Yeltsin has called for tougher measures to ensure that federal funds earmarked for social programs do not go astray in the regions, Russian news agencies reported on 10 March. Following a meeting with Yeltsin, Sysuev said the president is to appoint a commission to monitor how social benefits funds are allocated there. Sysuev and Mikhail Shmakov, the leader of the Federation of Independent Trade Unions, are to head that commission. According to Sysuev, Yeltsin sharply criticized some regional authorities for using federal funds "to solve their own problems." Regional officials say that because the federal government fails to meet its spending obligations, funds intended to pay wages, pensions, and child benefits sometimes must be diverted to pay for other vital needs, such as fuel supplies (see "RFE/RL Newsline," 14 January 1998). LB MINISTRY REGISTERS ROKHLIN'S MOVEMENT. The Justice Ministry on 10 March registered State Duma Defense Committee Chairman Lev Rokhlin's Movement to Support the Army, Rokhlin told Interfax. Last fall, the ministry refused to register the movement on the grounds that its charter does not describe it as a "political" movement, even though it is pursuing political aims. Rokhlin subsequently called a second congress of his movement to revise the charter (see "RFE/RL Newsline," 6 January 1998). He told Interfax that branches of the Movement to Support the Army have been formed in 68 out of Russia's 89 regions. Meanwhile, Duma deputy Aleksandr Shokhin on 10 March confirmed that the Our Home Is Russia Duma faction will continue its efforts to replace Rokhlin as Defense Committee chairman, ITAR-TASS reported. Last September, Rokhlin left the pro-government faction, which had nominated him for that post. LB AGENCY LEAVES RUSSIAN CREDIT RATING UNCHANGED. The international credit rating agency Fitch IBCA announced on 10 March that it has decided not to downgrade Russia's sovereign debt rating. The agency recently reviewed the financial situation in Russia. Some market analysts had expected a downgrade, because IBCA's rating for Russia was one notch higher than that of either Moody's or Standard & Poor's, Reuters reported. Both of those agencies are also considering whether a downgrade is warranted, but they have not yet announced their decision. A lower Russian sovereign debt rating would mean higher costs of foreign borrowing for both the government and commercial banks since those banks' credit ratings would automatically be lowered. LB LUZHKOV VOWS TO FLOUT COURT RULING. Moscow Mayor Yurii Luzhkov on 10 March announced that the capital will not do away with residence permits, ITAR-TASS reported. The Constitutional Court recently ruled that local authorities can keep records of citizens' places of residence but cannot use the registration process to grant or deny citizens permission to live in a given location (see "RFE/RL Newsline," 3 February 1998). Luzhkov called for overruling that decision, saying that residency permits (also known as "propiski") are needed to protect Moscow from an influx of citizens seeking benefits. He noted that social benefits payments already make up 41 percent of city budget expenditures. He did not specify how the court's decision could be overruled. Article 27 of the constitution grants citizens the right to choose their place of residence. LB CHICKEN LEGS TO PAY FOR TSAR'S BURIAL? "Novye izvestiya" reported on 10 March that proceeds from imports of chicken legs from the U.S. will fund the funeral for Russia's last tsar. Nicholas II and his family are to be buried in St. Petersburg this July, and the event will be financed from non-budgetary sources. "Novye izvestiya" alleged that a firm linked to Oneksimbank will import the chicken legs through the government commission on burying the tsar's remains, thereby gaining exemptions from various taxes and customs duties. First Deputy Prime Minister Boris Nemtsov heads that commission. The newspaper charged that Oneksimbank has unparalleled access to both Nemtsov and First Deputy Prime Minister Anatolii Chubais. "Novye izvestiya" was founded last year by journalists who left "Izvestiya," in which Oneksimbank is a major shareholder. Boris Berezovskii's LogoVAZ empire, a leading business rival of Oneksimbank, reportedly helps finance "Novye izvestiya." LB ARKHANGELSK SEEKS ILLEGAL 'CO-AUTHOR' OF OBLAST LAW. The Arkhangelsk Oblast Prosecutor's Office has opened a criminal case in connection with illegal alterations to a law on the oblast's human rights commissioner, "Izvestiya" reported on 11 March. The text published in the local press differed from the version of the law that had been approved by the oblast legislature and signed by Governor Anatolii Yefremov. For example, a passage prohibiting the commissioner from belonging to political parties or movements had been mysteriously removed. According to the 26 February edition of "IEWS Russian Regional Report," a scandal erupted in Arkhangelsk last October when the legislature appointed Yefremov's chief of staff as human rights commissioner. It emerged that the published version of the law had been revised to grant only the governor the right to nominate candidates for that post. A process to select a new commissioner is under way. LB NORTHERN PENSIONERS ANGRY ABOUT NEW LAW. Residents of Komi Republic are outraged over the federal law on the procedure for calculating pensions, which went into effect on 1 February, "Nezavisimaya gazeta" reported on 11 March. Moscow-based critics of the government say that pension increases have been insignificant under the new law (see "RFE/RL Newsline," 22 and 27 January 1998). Residents of Russia's northern regions have in fact seen their pensions decline, according to "Nezavisimaya gazeta." The law ties pension benefits to the number of years a citizen was working and does away with the practice of granting special benefits for those who worked in the Far North. Meanwhile, during his meeting with the North Caucasus elders on 10 March, Yeltsin promised that pensions will be raised by 20 percent in 1998 and increased further in coming years, ITAR-TASS reported. LB REGIONAL AFFAIRS LATVIA OFFICIALLY PROTESTS RUSSIAN RESPONSE TO PENSIONERS' RALLY... The Latvian Foreign Ministry on 10 March officially protested to Russia over Moscow's sharp criticism of the way Riga handled the 3 March rally staged by mainly ethnic Russian pensioners. Foreign Ministry spokesman Andrejs Pildegovic said a note that included a full description of the incident had been handed to the Russian ambassador. He commented that some remarks made by Russian officials over the incident "went beyond diplomatic and even ethical norms." He also said Latvian Foreign Minister Valdis Birkavs has suggested an official visit to Moscow to clarify Latvia's position and "directly inform" the Russian government and the State Duma on the incident. Also on 10 March, Birkavs's Estonian counterpart, Toomas Hendrik Ilves, said in Riga that "everything we have seen from the so-called incident is that Latvia behaved entirely properly and that the accusations made are groundless," Reuters reported. JC ...DENOUNCES DESECRATION OF SOVIET SOLDIERS' TOMB. The Latvian Foreign Ministry also expressed regret over the desecration of a tomb of Soviet soldiers in Liepaja, Latvia, BNS and ITAR-TASS reported. The statement came one day after the Russian Foreign Ministry had expressed outrage over the incident, claiming that vandalism is a logical extension of "nationalism, Russophobia, and trampling on human rights" in Latvia (see "RFE/RL Newsline," 10 March 1998). Riga appealed to Russian senior officials to refrain from "hasty and non-objective comments." It also expressed confidence that the Latvian authorities will conduct a thorough investigation into the incident and punish those responsible. JC TRANSCAUCASUS AND CENTRAL ASIA GEORGIA TO PRESENT NEW PLAN FOR CIS. Georgia will present a draft plan to the CIS summit in Moscow on 19-20 March calling for the establishment of a special commission to monitor CIS decisions and a special administrative region in Abkhazia's Gali district to facilitate the return of refugees. The plan also calls for CIS member states to turn to the UN and other international organizations if the CIS does not make progress soon on the Abkhaz crisis, Vakhtang Abashidze, a spokesman for Georgian President Eduard Shevardnadze told ITAR-TASS on 11 March. Abashidze added that the Georgian president has sent a letter to Russian President Boris Yeltsin arguing that it is well and good "if the CIS promotes the independence of CIS member countries"; if it does not, then "disintegration processes may develop" within the commonwealth. Abashidze said the letter made clear that CIS membership must not block expanded ties between member states and European and international institutions. PG ATTACK AT ARMENIAN ELECTION RALLY STILL GRABBING HEADLINES. The 8 March attack on participants at an election rally held by supporters of Vazgen Manukian in the town of Ararat continues to dominate the presidential campaign, RFE/RL's Armenian Service reported on 10 March. While Manukian expressed his satisfaction with the way the authorities are investigating the matter, other candidates have either criticized the government or sought to place the blame for the attack on one or another faction. Acting President and Prime Minister Robert Kocharian suggested that the attack was directed "against the prestige of our country and me personally." Meanwhile, Self-Determination Union candidate Paruir Hayrikian suggested to Kocharian that he withdraw as a presidential candidate but continue as premier. PG ANOTHER UZBEK OFFICIAL SACKED. Uzbek President Islam Karimov signed a decree on 10 March dismissing Deputy Prime Minister Komiljon Rakhimov, ITAR-TASS reported. The news agency commented that Rakhimov has been relieved of his duties "on the traditional pretext of being transferred to another post," which "usually means a considerable reduction in rank." Last week, a security adviser to the president was replaced (See "RFE/RL Newsline," 5 March 1998). BP KAZAKH NAVY TO PATROL CASPIAN SEA. Tursun Uazhanov, a senior official from the Kazakh border guards, said that beginning this spring, Kazakh navy vessels will patrol the Kazakh section of the Caspian Sea, Interfax reported on 10 March. Uazhanov said initially naval operations will focus on "countermeasures against poaching." But he added that once there is an official division of the Caspian, "we will start full-fledged patrolling of our maritime borders." BP END NOTE WHAT PRICE BAKU-CEYHAN? by Lowell Bezanis and Liz Fuller At the beginning of this month, Turkish Foreign Minister Ismail Cem invited his counterparts from Georgia, Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan, and Turkmenistan to attend talks in Istanbul aimed at reaching a consensus on the merits of what may prove to be a $2.5 billion white elephant The project in question is the planned 1,730 kilometer pipeline from Baku via Georgia to the southern Turkish terminal at Ceyhan, which could pump 35-50 million tons of Caspian oil a year to a soft Mediterranean market. The Baku-Ceyhan route is one of three options for the so-called Main Export Pipeline (MEP) currently being evaluated by the government of Azerbaijan and the Azerbaijan International Operating Company (AIOC), which is developing three Azerbaijani offshore oil fields. The others are the northern route from Baku via Grozny to Novorossiisk and the western route through Georgia to the Black Sea port of Supsa. The final choice is slated for October 1998 but may well be postponed. Turkey's publicly stated reason for plugging Baku-Ceyhan is to preclude an increase in the volume of oil tanker traffic through the Turkish Straits, which could pose a serious environmental hazard to Istanbul and its population of 10 million as well as slow up traffic in an already congested waterway. Another complication is that the projected volume of AIOC oil--2 million barrels a day to come on stream years from now--could be consumed by the Black Sea littoral states, including Turkey, which imports about 700,000 barrels a day. Romania, Bulgaria, and Ukraine also have an interest in using Caspian oil for domestic consumption and possibly re-export. In any event, the MEP could not rely on AIOC oil alone but would have to include not only volumes from fields currently still being explored in the Caspian but also Kazakh and possibly Turkmen oil, too. Turkey remains upbeat, however, not only because the project is viewed as a means to realize Ankara's geopolitical ambitions and its bid to become a regional energy and transport hub for Caspian and Central Asian gas but also because Washington is aggressively supporting the Turkish leadership as part of a larger scheme to funnel gas westward via Turkey by piggy-backing gas and oil pipelines. Turkey needs gas to fuel power plants worth $40 billion to be tendered in the next decade. As for the producer and other potential transit countries, Azerbaijan has repeatedly affirmed its preference for the Baku-Ceyhan route, although Azerbaijani oil is already being exported northward through the Baku-Grozny-Novorossiisk pipeline. Turkmenistan and Kazakhstan see Baku-Ceyhan as a possible alternative or additional outlet to international markets. But that would likely necessitate laying a technically problematic underwater Trans-Caspian pipeline to Baku, which Russia and Iran jointly oppose. Turkmenistan's only other export routes are via Iran or Afghanistan. Kazakhstan has a choice between the westward-bound Tengiz-Astrakhan-Novorossiisk pipeline and eastwards via China but will go with whichever pipeline is operational first. It will also likely pursue a swap option with Iran, which many in the AIOC would presumably like to see if only Washington would tolerate it. Georgia, meanwhile, will be laughing all the way to the bank whether the MEP terminates in Supsa or Ceyhan. Russia wants to see the bulk of oil flow north and argues--with justification--that the northern route is more economical. But the U.S., whose oil companies are major players in the Caspian, favors Baku-Ceyhan as a means of anchoring Azerbaijan, Georgia, and Turkey to the West and thereby further undercutting Russia's already waning influence in the Transcaucasus. In the event, the Istanbul talks revealed significant differences between Turkey and all participants except Georgia and failed to result in an unequivocal public endorsement of the Baku-Ceyhan option, as Turkey had hoped. The talks also irked Russia, which was not invited to participate. But that does not necessarily reflect a lack of determination to proceed and to find ways of buying off Moscow. Since 1994, Turkey has been talking about Russian participation in Baku-Ceyhan on the production side. It also wants to see Russian oil exported through Baku-Ceyhan. In late January, Cem floated the idea of giving "all regional states," including Russia, a cut of the profits from exporting Caspian oil to Ceyhan. That offer is likely to engender more cut-throat, behind-the-scenes bargaining. Given the magnitude of the stakes involved, Georgian President Eduard Shevardnadze's 2 March assertion that "an oil pipeline is not a tug-of-war" is simply wishful thinking. Lowell Bezanis is a Washington-based specialist in Turkish and Transcaucasian affairs. xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Copyright (c) 1998 RFE/RL, Inc. All rights reserved. xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx HOW TO SUBSCRIBE Send an email to firstname.lastname@example.org with the word "subscribe" as the subject or body of the message. HOW TO UNSUBSCRIBE Send an email to email@example.com with the word "unsubscribe" as the subject or body of the message. HOW TO RETRIEVE BACK ISSUES VIA EMAIL (1) Send an email to firstname.lastname@example.org with the letters "ls" as the subject or body of the message. This will retrieve a list of available files. (2) Send an email to email@example.com with the phrase "get x" (x being the name of the file you would like to receive) as the subject or body of the message. _________________________________________________ CURRENT AND BACK ISSUES ON THE WEB Back issues of RFE/RL Newsline and the OMRI Daily Digest are online at: http://www.rferl.org/newsline/search/ _________________________________________________ LISTEN TO NEWS FOR 18 COUNTRIES RFE/RL programs for countries in Eastern Europe, the Caucasus, Central Asia, Russia and the South Slavic region are online daily at RFE/RL's 24-Hour LIVE Broadcast Studio. http://www.rferl.org/realaudio/index.html _________________________________________________ REPRINT POLICY To receive reprint permission, please contact Paul Goble, Publisher Email: GobleP@rferl.org Phone: 202-457-6947 Fax: 202-457-6992 Postal Address: RFE/RL, 1201 Connecticut Ave., NW Washington, DC 20036 USA _________________________________________________ RFE/RL NEWSLINE STAFF * Paul Goble, Publisher, GobleP@rferl.org * Liz Fuller, Editor-in-Chief, CarlsonE@rferl.org * Patrick Moore, Team Leader, MooreP@rferl.org * Laurie Belin, BelinL@rferl.org * Bruce Pannier, PannierB@rferl.org * Michael Shafir, ShafirM@rferl.org * Jan Cleave, CleaveJ@rferl.org Freelance And Occasional Contributors * Fabian Schmidt * Matyas Szabo * Pete Baumgartner * Jeremy Bransten * Jolyon Naegele * Anthony Wesolowsky * Julia Guechakov RFE/RL Newsline Fax: (420-2) 2112-3630 _________________________________________________ RADIO FREE EUROPE / RADIO LIBERTY, PRAGUE, CZECH REPUBLIC
write to us
with your comments and suggestions.