|To appreciate nonsense requires a serious interest in life. - Gelett Burgess|
RFE/RL NEWSLINE Vol. 1, No. 128, Part II, 30 September 1997
A daily report of developments in Eastern and Southeastern Europe, Russia, the Caucasus and Central Asia prepared by the staff of Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty. This is Part II, a compilation of news concerning Central, Eastern, and Southeastern Europe. Part I covers Russia, Transcaucasia and Central Asia and is distributed simultaneously as a second document. Back issues of RFE/RL NewsLine and the OMRI Daily Digest are online at RFE/RL's Web site: http://www.rferl.org/newsline RUSSIAN MEDIA EMPIRES. Government and business entities control many major Russian media. This special report on the RFE/RL Web site lists the important players. http://www.rferl.org/nca/special/rumedia/index.html xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Headlines, Part II *COUNCIL OF EUROPE NOT TO INVITE BELARUSIAN PRESIDENT *HUNGARY INVITES SLOVAKIA FOR TALKS OVER DAM *SPEAKER OF BOSNIAN PARLIAMENT DENOUNCES PLAVSIC End Note LATVIA LEADS WAY ON PENSION REFORM xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx EAST-CENTRAL EUROPE COUNCIL OF EUROPE NOT TO INVITE BELARUSIAN PRESIDENT. In the latest international snub to Alyaksandr Lukashenka, Jacques Warin, the French representative to the Council of Europe, has said the body will not invite the Belarusian leader to the 10-11 October summit in Strasbourg. France, which currently holds the rotating presidency of the council, is the host of that meeting. Russian President Boris Yeltsin and other leaders of council member states are expected to attend. In January 1997, the council suspended Belarus's "special guest" status as a non-member country. ORT REPORTER SMUGGLES OUT LETTER FROM HRODNO PRISON. Pavel Sheremet, the Russian Public Television bureau chief in Minsk, has smuggled out a letter about conditions in the Hrodno detention center where he is being held, Interfax-West reported on 29 September. The letter, published in "Belorusskaya delovaya gazeta" the same day, said his fellow prisoners are "quite tolerable." But he suggested that his experience in prison has left him with "contempt for this insane authority. Over the past two months, I have clearly realized that inmates should not be feared. One must fear those who wear uniforms." Meanwhile, President Lukashenka told Interfax that he would not discuss the Sheremet case at his 30 September meeting with visiting Russian Deputy Premier Valerii Serov. DRUZHBA PIPELINE CROSSING BELARUS NEEDS REPAIRS. Officials at the Novopolotsk and Homel oil transit enterprises told Belapan on 29 September that the Druzhba pipeline carrying oil from Russia to Central Europe is at risk unless repairs are made soon. But the officials, whom the news agency did not name, said they do not have the money to repair the line. "Gudok" on 27 September reported that unnamed Western companies engaged in exploiting Caspian oil have already agreed to finance repairs to the stretch of the Druzhba pipeline that crosses Ukraine. KUCHMA WELCOMES RUSSIAN-UKRAINIAN ACCORD. Ukrainian President Leonid Kuchma said on 29 September that Moscow and Kyiv have no fundamental differences in approach to foreign policy questions, ITAR-TASS reported. He was speaking after representatives to the newly established Ukrainian-Russian Consultative Council handed him a document calling for the two sides to raise their "relations to the level of strategic partnership." Kuchma also said he will make an informal visit to Moscow to meet with Russian President Yeltsin before his official trip to the Russian capital in January. MOSCOW REPORTEDLY DEVELOPS NEW BALTIC POLICY. Russian Foreign Minister Yevgenii Primakov told his Latvian counterpart, Valdis Birkavs, in New York recently that Moscow is developing a new policy toward the Baltic States, BNS reported 29 September. Primakov said the policy is being developed according to instructions from Yeltsin. Birkavs told BNS that Moscow's new approach appears to accentuate the positive rather than harping on the negative. He noted, however, that Primakov repeated Russia's objections to the Baltic States' desire to join NATO. ESTONIAN MANIFESTO FAILS OWING TO 'POLITICAL SUSPICIONS.' Andres Tarand, one of the signatories to the 26 September Manifesto of Seven, told BNS on 29 September that the initiative has failed because of the "suspicions" of many political figures in the country. The manifesto is entitled "What Kind of a State Do We Want?" and was circulated by foreign minister Toomas Hendrik Ilves. It warns that populism could threaten Estonia's progress and calls for a new focus on domestic problems. But many politicians and commentators suggest that the document is simply an attempt to launch a new political party. LATVIAN, UKRAINIAN LEADERS BACK REGIONAL SUMMIT PLANS. Ukrainian President Kuchma said that several European countries have backed his call for a 1999 Baltic-Black Sea summit in Yalta, Interfax reported on 29 September. His remarks came during a visit to Kyiv by Latvian President Guntis Ulmanis, who said he too supports the idea. The 1999 meeting would be a follow up to the European security conference held in Vilnius in early September. POLISH PRESIDENT ASKS SOLIDARITY TO FORM GOVERNMENT. Aleksander Kwasniewski on 29 September asked Solidarity Electoral Action (AWS) to present its candidate for premier by 17 October, Reuters reported. AWS chairman Marian Krzaklewski, told journalists following his meeting with Kwasniewski that the AWS's candidate will be presented by that time. "We expect that the president will entrust this candidate with the task of forming a government, " he added. Krzaklewski refused to reveal the AWS's choice for premier, confirming only that he will not take the post himself. The AWS won the elections with 201 seats in the 460-seat lower house but must form a coalition with smaller parties to have a solid majority. It has started coalition talks with the 27-seat strong Peasant Party and the six-seat populist Movement for the Renovation of Poland. But it is most likely to form a cabinet with the market-friendly Union for Freedom, which has 60 seats. U.S. OFFICIAL CAUTIONS CZECHS OVER NATO MEMBERSHIP. Assistant Defense Secretary Frank Kramer, who recently visited the Czech Republic, Poland, and Hungary, told Czech officials they need to increase both military spending (which declined sharply in the past 12 months) and support among Czechs for NATO membership, Reuters reported on 29 September, quoting a U.S. Defense Department spokesman. Kramer also noted that the Czech Republic is lagging behind Poland and Hungary as the three states prepare to join NATO. Kramer held talks in Prague on 16 September with Defense Minister Miloslav Vyborny, who is scheduled to join U.S. Defense Secretary William Cohen and other NATO defense ministers at a two-day meeting in The Netherlands beginning on 1 October to discuss NATO expansion. CHARGES NOT TO BE BROUGHT AGAINST SLOVAK INTERIOR MINISTER. The Prosecutor-General on 29 September dropped charges against Interior Minister Gustav Krajci, who had been accused of thwarting a referendum on NATO membership and direct presidential elections, TASR reported. The move came because of insufficient evidence that a crime had been committed. It had been alleged that Krajci ensured the invalidity of the referendum by omitting the question about presidential elections from ballot papers. HUNGARY INVITES SLOVAKIA FOR TALKS OVER DAM. Hungarian Prime Minister Gyula Horn on 29 September invited his Slovak counterpart, Vladimir Meciar, for talks to discuss the disputed Gabcikovo-Nagymaros hydropower project on the River Danube. The move comes after the International Court of Justice in The Hague ruled that the two states must respect the terms of the 1977 treaty, which requires Bratislava and Budapest to negotiate in good faith. Hungary and Slovakia took the issue to the court in 1992, after the Slovaks diverted the Danube to Slovak territory to supply a power station at Gabcikovo. Earlier, in 1989, Hungary had unilaterally suspended work on its side, citing environmental concerns. HUNGARIAN FOREIGN MINISTER ON NATO TALKS. Laszlo Kovacs, who is visiting Washington, says he expects NATO to be satisfied with Budapest's defense budget. He said Hungary will spend less than requested by NATO but noted that military spending will be roughly equal to that of smaller NATO member countries, such as Belgium or Portugal, Reuters reported. Together with his Polish counterpart, Darius Rosati, and Czech Deputy Foreign Minister Karel Kovanda, Kovacs met with National Security Adviser Sandy Berger at the White House on 29 September. Berger acknowledged that the three countries are making "serious efforts" to prepare for NATO membership. SOUTHEASTERN EUROPE SPEAKER OF BOSNIAN PARLIAMENT DENOUNCES PLAVSIC. Slobodan Bijelic, the Bosnian Serb speaker of the all Bosnian parliament, told SRNA on 29 September that Republika Srpska President Biljana Plavsic, has already violated the 24 September Belgrade agreement by postponing parliamentary elections by eight days until 23 November. He said her unilateral move could contribute to the further disintegration of Republika Srpska and to a "renewed flare up of emotions." Meanwhile, Momcilo Krajisnik, the Bosnian Serb co- president of Bosnia, met with Yugoslav President Slobodan Milosevic in Belgrade on 29 September. According to Tanjug, the two leaders said that "an important step forward" was taken when the Bosnian collective Presidency agreed that Republika Srpska citizens will be able to apply for Yugoslav citizenship in addition to retaining their status as citizens of Bosnia-Herzegovina. BOSNIAN SERB PREMIER WARNS AGAINST ARRESTING KARADZIC. Republika Srpska Prime Minister Gojko Klickovic, speaking on Montenegrin Television on 27 September, said that arresting Radovan Karadzic "would lead to a complete collapse of the Dayton Agreement and new conflicts in Bosnia-Herzegovina." He said the international community will "gain nothing if they destroy the 80 percent of the Dayton Agreement implemented so far." Klickovic stressed that the Serbs will not "give up" Karadzic, who, he added, has withdrawn from all political functions and "is just doing his earlier job." But Klickovic stressed that Karadzic is still a leader and that his name cannot simply be forgotten. According to Klickovic, Karadzic "is now forced to hide, although he is guilty of nothing except defending his people." The Bosnian Serb premier argued that no one has any evidence of his guilt, Montena-Fax reported. KOSOVAR STUDENTS PLEDGE TO PROCEED WITH PROTESTS. Ethnic Albanian students in Kosovo have rejected pleas by Kosovar leader Ibrahim Rugova and a visiting delegation of Belgrade-based diplomats to postpone protests due to begin in seven Kosovo towns on 1 October. Senior diplomats from the U.S., Russia, and European countries argued that the protests should not take place between the first and second rounds of the Serbian elections. The students are protesting the failure to implement an Albanian-language education agreement signed in 1996 by Rugova and then Serbian President Slobodan Milosevic. The diplomats met separately with Rugova and local Serbian authorities. Veljko Odalovic, the Serb-appointed deputy leader of Kosovo, told the delegation that ethnic Albanian political leaders must give up the idea of an independent Kosovo. MONTENEGRIN PRESIDENT SEEKS MUSLIM, ALBANIAN VOTE. Momir Bulatovic, who is running for reelection as president, took his campaign to the multi-ethnic mountain town of Plav near the border with Albania and Kosovo . He told a crowd of several thousand people that "what hurts most is the fact that an attempt is being made to divide us along ethnic lines.... I hope that Muslims and [ethnic] Albanians will vote like full-fledged citizens in line with their beliefs," Radio Belgrade reported on 29 September. Bulatovic added that "enormous pressure is being exerted on Muslim and ethnic Albanian residents by the secret police," which he accused of "spreading untruths and fear." FORMER CROATIAN CHIEF OF STAFF DENOUNCES TUDJMAN. General Anton Tus, in an interview with the Rijeka daily "Novi list" on 27 September, accused President Franjo Tudjman of having "frequently subordinated military operations to political decisions" during fighting against the Yugoslav Army (JNA) and rebel Serbs in 1991- 1992 and 1995. Tus said Tudjman foiled his attempt to lift the Serbian siege of Vukovar in 1992 by yielding to EU pressure to grant passage to a humanitarian convoy. Tus says he ignored Tudjman's orders not to attack JNA barracks and seized military facilities in Karlovac, Bjelovar, Delnice, Samobor, and Buna. He added that Tudjman opposed his suggestions, at the end of 1992 and again in 1995, to take western Bosnia and the area along Bosnia's Sava river area. Tus was Tudjman's chief military adviser until fall 1995. ALBANIAN SUPREME COURT OVERTURNS CONVICTIONS. The Supreme Court on 29 September overturned the convictions of all 32 former communist officials sentenced to prison for crimes against humanity. Brief verdicts read by Supreme Court Chairman Avni Shehu declared the former officials innocent of "genocide," for which they had been sentenced by lower courts. Prosecutors said the charges were dropped because communist Albanian legislation did not refer to such a crime. They noted that the former officials should have been prosecuted for abuse of power, for which many have already been sentenced. Only four of the former leaders are serving time. Shehu said they will be freed. ROMANIA'S FORMER INTELLIGENCE CHIEF ON POLITICAL AIMS. In an interview with RFE/RL's Bucharest bureau, Virgil Magureanu, the former director of the Romanian Intelligence Service, has denied he intends to set up a new political party (see "RFE/RL Newsline," 29 September 1997). Magureanu said he wants to "contribute" to the setting up of a "center-left" political alliance, which, he believes, will come into being "within two months." He also said it is not his intention to head the new alliance but to be a member of its leadership. ROMANIAN PRESIDENT PROMOTES EU MEMBERSHIP. Emil Constantinescu, meeting in Brussels on 29 September with European Commission President Jacques Santer, again argued in favor of simultaneous negotiations with all candidates for EU membership, an RFE/RL correspondent in Brussels reported. Constantinescu also met with Belgian Prime Minister Jean-Luc Dehaene. In other news, the Senate on 29 September amended a 1990 law on compensation to victims of the communist dictatorship. The legislation provides for monthly payments of 60,000 lei (about $7.50) for each year spent in prison or as a deportee abroad and 30,000 lei for each year spent in psychiatric wards as punishment. The law applies also to Romanian citizens residing abroad. MOLDOVA CRITICIZES CONTINUED RUSSIAN PRESENCE IN TRANSDNIESTER. Addressing the UN General Assembly on 29 September, Moldovan Foreign Minister Nicolae Tabacaru said Russia is stalling over the withdrawal of its troops and weapons from the breakaway Transdniester region, ITAR-TASS reported. In response, Aleksandr Gorelik, Russia's deputy permanent representative at the UN, said the Moldovan position contradicts the agreements reached at the recent meeting in Moscow between the two countries' presidents. He said that according to those agreements, the withdrawal should not be "hasty" in order to prevent "creating a situation beyond control, especially [given] the large arsenals of weapons in this area." RUSSIA WITHDRAWS EQUIPMENT FROM TRANSDNIESTER. Colonel Aleksandr Baranov, the deputy commander of the Russian troops stationed in the Transdniester, told journalists on 29 September that 49 railroad cars have been loaded with engineering equipment and will leave for Russia "in the next days," RFE/RL's Chisinau bureau reported. Infotag reported the same day that a convoy left on 27 September. Observers note that such equipment has been withdrawn in the past and that the latest move does not necessarily mean an end to the dispute over ownership of Russian armaments in the region. A military adviser to Igor Smirnov, the leader of the breakaway republic, said the Russian military equipment will be sold "in line with the agreement reached between Russia and the Transdniester." The adviser added that "Moldova has no right whatever" to those weapons. BULGARIAN NUCLEAR WASTE POSES ENVIRONMENTAL PROBLEM. Some 15,000 cubic meters of fluid radioactive waste from the Kozloduy nuclear plant threaten the environment along the River Danube, BTA reported on 29 September. Citing experts from the Academy of Sciences, the agency said the waste is being stored in containers. A reprocessing plant for the waste has not yet been built. In other news, President Petar Stoyanov on 29 September began a three-day private visit to Germany at the invitation of the Konrad Adenauer Foundation. He will meet with German President Roman Herzog. END NOTE LATVIA LEADS WAY ON PENSION REFORM by Michael Wyzan All transition countries are dealing with problems posed by the pension systems they inherited. The difficulties are similar to those currently experienced by many advanced and developing countries that now find themselves with systems they cannot afford. Moreover, those systems provide disincentives for the working-age population to find employment in the formal sector (meaning those enterprises that pay taxes and social insurance contributions) and to save. The pension systems used by most countries are provided by the state on a "pay-as-you-go" (PAYG) basis and offer "defined benefits" to retirees. The pensions paid to current retirees are funded by contributions from current workers. A retiree's pension is determined in advance according to various criteria (age, gender, length of employment). It does not reflect the contributions that the retiree paid into the system during his working life. In developed countries, PAYG systems become problematic as the population ages and the number of beneficiaries increases relative to the number of contributors. People retiring during the first years of such a system receive pensions that exceed the amount they paid in. Later generations, on the other hand, receive less than they contributed. Moreover, people can retire before they reach the official retirement age, with only a small reduction in benefits. To fund such largesse, high payroll taxes are necessary, which people avoid by working in the informal sector. Such practice reduces the tax base and requires still higher taxes on those who cannot avoid them. In Latin America and the former communist countries, there are additional problems. In the former East bloc, in particular, retirement ages are low, especially for women and in certain sectors. Many countries have reformed their pension systems. In 1981, Chile replaced its PAYG system with a mandatory savings scheme, whereby a worker's pension is financed by a savings account into which he pays during his working life. That pension depends on the contribution rate, the growth in the worker's salary, the interest rate, and the number of years at work and in retirement. Such schemes are "fully funded," because a worker's contribution finances all his benefits, and are based on "defined contributions," which are determined in advance. "Averting the Old Age Crisis," a book published in 1994 by the World Bank, outlines a recommended "three-pillar" pension reform. Acknowledging the popularity of PAYG schemes, especially among older workers, the bank proposes that the first pillar be mandatory, tax-financed, and publicly managed. The second pillar is mandatory, fully funded, privately managed, and publicly regulated (as in Chile). The third pillar differs from the second one largely in that it is voluntary. Among transition countries, Latvia was the first to heed the bank's recommendations on pension reform (with Poland, Estonia, and Hungary following its lead). Riga benefited from technical assistance offered by Sweden, which in 1994 passed legislation providing for a two-pillar system. In the summer of 1995, Latvia passed similar laws. A new PAYG system based on "notional accounts" went into effect in Latvia on 1 January 1996, while a funded scheme will begin in 2000. Such accounts differ from the standard PAYG system in that an individual account is maintained for each worker, although benefits are paid by someone else's contributions. The contribution rate is 20 percent of income, of which 2 percent will be channeled to the funded ("second") pillar as of 2000. In time, 6-7 percent of income will go toward the second pillar. Privately managed individual accounts will be provided to workers born in or after 1949. At retirement, a worker receives a PAYG annuity based on the balance in his notional account and his life expectancy. PAYG benefits are indexed to price inflation until 2000 and thereafter to both price inflation and wage growth. Retirement can be either partial or full after age 60, and additional wages earned during partial retirement add to the balance of the notional account and increase the benefits. There is also a "social pension" for the elderly poor who are not eligible for any other such payment. That pension is currently set at 25 percent of the average wage. The new system pays benefits to anyone who worked in the formal sector for 10 years. Participation does not depend on citizenship, so the system does not discriminate against the Russian minority. Pension reform is one of several examples of radical economic measures undertaken by both Latvia and its northern neighbor, Estonia. Others include a currency board (Estonia), a tough line toward failed banks (both), and a favorable attitude toward foreign investors (especially Estonia). It is striking that such measures have occurred amid unstable political environments, especially in Latvia, with its frequent changes of ministers and governments. It is even more striking that Latvia has been able to undertake a more comprehensive pension reform than more advanced and prosperous countries such as the Czech Republic or Slovenia--not to mention France or the U.S. The author is a research scholar at the International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis in Laxenburg, Austria. xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Copyright (c) 1997 RFE/RL, Inc. All rights reserved. xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx SUBSCRIBING: 1) To subscribe to RFERL-L, please send a message to email@example.com 2) In the text of your message, type subscribe RFERL-L YourFirstName YourLastName UNSUBSCRIBING: 1) To un-subscribe to RFERL-L, please send a message to firstname.lastname@example.org 2) In the text of your message, type unsubscribe RFERL-L Current and Back Issues Back issues of RFE/RL Newsline and the OMRI Daily Digest are online at: http://www.rferl.org/newsline/search/ Listen to news for 13 countries RFE/RL programs for countries in the Caucasus, Central Asia, Russia and the South Slavic region are online daily at RFE/RL's 24-Hour LIVE Broadcast Studio. http://www.rferl.org/realaudio/index.html Reprint Policy To receive reprint permission, please contact Paul Goble, Publisher Email: GobleP@rferl.org Phone: 202-457-6947 Fax: 202-457-6992 Postal Address: RFE/RL, 1201 Connecticut Ave., NW Washington, DC 20036 USA RFE/RL Newsline Staff: * Paul Goble, Publisher, GobleP@rferl.org * Liz Fuller, Acting Editor (Transcaucasia) CarlsonE@rferl.org * Patrick Moore, Acting Deputy Editor (West Balkans) MooreP@rferl.org * Michael Shafir (East Balkans) ShafirM@rferl.org * Laura Belin (Russia) BelinL@rferl.org * Bruce Pannier (Central Asia) PannierB@rferl.org * Jan Cleave, CleaveJ@rferl.org * Mike Gallant, GallantM@rferl.org RFE/RL Newsline Fax: (420-2) 2112-3630
write to us
with your comments and suggestions.